On Bipeds & Brutes

National Museum of Animals & Society Blog

No Animals Were Harmed?

Movie poster, 1925. Image via Wikipedia.

Movie poster, 1925. Image via Wikipedia.

Think of an epic film. There’s a good chance your mind wandered to something along the lines of Braveheart or Lord of the Rings. There’s also a good chance you immediately pictured one of the vast battle sequences where our heroes clash magnificently against their foes on horseback. Well, what about the horses? They fall under arrow-fire, get hewn down by sword and axe, and trample each other. There is a lot of authenticity to these scenes, as real epic warfare featured many painful and hideous casualties for soldier and warhorse alike; but to what extent do films try to capture this verisimilitude?

Prior to 1940, there was no regulation in the treatment of animals in film. In such classics as Ben Hur (1925), animals were killed through accidents or negligence on-set, or, more horrifically, intentionally for dramatic purposes. This all changed after the 1939 film Jesse James, where a horse was driven off a cliff to its death, sparking public outrage. The American Humane Association (AHA), a group dedicated to the welfare of animals and children, began to police Hollywood with their Film and Television Unit, famous for their “No Animals Were Harmed” disclaimer.

Still, films as late as the 1990s continued inhumane practices on their animal actors, particularly in epic battle sequences. Where a charge of horses was required, the common practice was to use trip-wires on the unsuspecting animals, which caused them to fall down violently, and sometimes resulted in injuries such as cuts or, in the worst cases, broken legs. This procedure has fallen out of favor largely due to the policing of the AHA, but also because of economic concerns. Quite simply, it costs more to hurt the animals and have to replace them.

Over the last few decades, and due to ever-enhancing technology, there are now many work-arounds that accomplish the realistic drama of warfare without harming the animals involved. There are trainers who specialize in raising stunt horses for use in films. These horses are trained to perform a simple forward fall by turning their heads and buckling their knees, in return for some reward. The work of the animals on-set is heavily monitored by the AHA. While these real animals add life to a scene technology cannot perfectly imitate, the safest methods are implemented by using as few real animals as possible. For the climactic battle in Braveheart (1995), a combination of trained real horses and realistic mechanical stunt doubles were used. In more recent epic films — the Lord of the Rings trilogy being one of the most notable — horses were used for riding, but were almost completely absent from the large-scale battle sequences; instead the director opted to save both effort and money with digitally-inserted horses. They still lend the dramatic weight when the heroes charge into battle, and they still look every inch as majestic. But these horses can come to no harm, and I’d say that’s the most humane film-making method Hollywood has.

See also The Fifth Estate’s Cruelty on Film timeline, a list of notable films by year where animals were either injured or killed during filming.


2 responses to “No Animals Were Harmed?

  1. Mackenzie | Red Roan Chronicles September 1, 2011 at 2:06 pm

    Great post. The advances in CGI that are finally allowing for truly life-like animal action I think is one of the best advances to happen for animals in film. Not only are they not subjected to such dangerous conditions anymore, they also don’t have to be laboriously trained for certain behaviors, either. I LOVE films with horses in them but they can be very difficult to watch, especially the older ones, when you see what’s been done to the horses for the sake of the film.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: